Maybe Moms Judging Each Other Isn’t the Worst Thing In the World


mom judging each otherOh, judging.

If judging were an Olympic sport, moms would medal every time. Seriously, we’d be victory dancing like Usain Bolt and slow clapping like an 80s movie. Am I right?

When it comes to judging one another, moms are THE WORST. Moms judging one another is a tale as old as time.

Now listen, this is not an indictment. For one, I’m a mom and I tend to judge as much as the next gal — I don’t exactly have a leg to stand on in this department. For another, indicting other moms is pretty much the same as judging them. I looked it up.

What I want to say is that not all judging is bad. Quite frankly, some of it can be quite helpful and illuminating for our own parenting. I’m not talking about giving the side-eye to a mom who permits her child to climb UP the slide (the horror!) or gasping in shock at a woman breastfeeding in public (breasts, how terrifying!).

Maybe judging each other isn’t so bad? If it comes from a desire to learn more about what we want, I say bring it on!

Allow me give you a few examples from my own life.

I have a dear friend who has this beautiful and clean house. It’s spectacular. Her pantry looks the way I imagine Gwyneth’s looking (as if it was arranged by tiny little pantry-elves that only shop at Whole Foods). She can keep her amazingly decorated house clean and organized, even when her three-year-old is running around like a crazy man. Girl just KNOWS what to do and where EVERYTHING goes. It makes her feel happy when everything is in place.

Another friend of mine is this rock star nutritionist. Like, “makes her own almond milk” and “feeds her willing toddler Brussels sprouts” kind of rock star nutritionist. She’s passionate about food and making sure her family eats the real stuff. Lady spends so. much. time. in the kitchen because it is her studio, her office.

I could easily feel inferior to these two women in my life. After all, organization is not my forte and my toddler just tried cat food for the first time this morning (loved it, by the way). But here’s the thing about those things: they’re just not “my thing.” You know what I mean?

And it wasn’t until I embraced the idea of moms judging each other that I learned more about myself.

We all have our things that we fight for in this crazy world of parenting. Our battlegrounds. Maybe yours is eating only organic food or not watching any television. Or maybe getting your child to sleep through the night is the hill you’re willing to die on. The thing is, looking at the amazing mothers around me and seeing where their battlefields are helps me figure out mine. The key is to let myself off the hook when something isn’t my “thing” and to let other mothers off the hook when something isn’t theirs.

We can’t do it all. Sad face emoji. But we can’t! Even Giselle Bundchen with her private chef and dreamy husband can’t fight every battle. The best we can do is figure out what is most important to us to impart on our children and then pray to whatever god we believe in that we have the energy to do it.

Examining another’s parenting style is part of the process. But rather than judging one another in a burn-book-circa-middle-school kind of way, let’s learn from each other. If anything, this approach helps me feel more secure in my parenting. I look around at my amazing friends and the gifts they bring to their parenting approaches and I feel inspired rather than defeated. I pick up their tricks for the things they are passionate about and share mine. From observing, I can discern what my parenting style is and where I want to spend my limited energy. (Discern is a synonym for “judging”…I looked it up).

I grow my own vegetables. My children do yoga with me. I stay home with them most days. Microfashion is one of my loves.

Some moms use a toddler leash so they won’t lose their children. Others continue breastfeeding past the first year. Some mothers say “never” to screens and others rank their favorite kids shows.

Rather than roll your eyes at any of that stuff, see if it helps you figure out what you’re willing to put up a fight for. Moms judging one another isn’t so bad in the end — it helped me figured out what was important to me. 

Previous articleToddler Leash: A Lesson in Mothering
Next articleMaking The Leap: Early Chapter Books for Your Young Reader
Allison’s mission in life is to notice the extraordinary in the ordinary. Her commitment to see beyond what’s in front of her was fostered by her degree in Philosophy and Theology from Boston College. Allison’s a book nerd and credits her parents and inspiring English teachers for her love of reading and writing. She went on to earn her Master in Pastoral Ministry from Boston College and then taught high school for several years, both in New England and San Francisco. After moving from San Francisco to Boston with her engineer husband, she began teaching yoga and working as a social media marketing consultant. Now a Portsmouth resident, she spends most of her days with her three daughters (she does not have enough arms) and does her best to find the bliss amidst the endless snacking, dance parties and tiaras. With all the beautiful chaos in her life, she’s grateful to have her partner-in-crime (husband Charlie) and fellow movie quote enthusiast alongside her. Her passion for writing first drew her to Seacoast Moms as a contributing writer, and her desire to connect moms of the Seacoast with businesses who serve and interest them led her to become SM’s owner. Being able to write about the ordinary grace present in motherhood, while interacting with incredible Seacoast business owners is a dream come true.


  1. beautiful you~ i loved everything about this! and truly needed to read this!!! you are awesome! thank you for such a great post! and…my 3 year old loved cat food too when she tried it! seriously, these toddlers!! ha!

  2. I love this post. As a mom who chose not to breastfeed, worked full-time, and had to put a 13-week-old in daycare — I felt judged. I felt judged for not losing the baby weight and for having a baby with a helmet. We need to remember not to beat ourselves up or judge other moms for the good or the bad. Great post!

  3. Zoe prefers dog food. Discerning toddler taste, you know! We all judge ourselves most harshly! Loved this Allison! You’re awesome.

  4. Love this post, Ally! Thanks for continuing to shed light on the important parts of this parenting journey. Your writing is a gift to all of us ❤️.

Comments are closed.